Merino or synthetic base layer: which to wear and when


Merino stays warm when damp and doesn't smell. Synthetic dries faster and costs less. How each works, which suits your activity, and the ones we make.
A base layer is the layer of clothing next to your skin. Its job is to keep sweat off your skin, so you stay warm when you stop and don't overheat when you're working hard.
The short answer to merino or synthetic: merino for stop-start days, cold weather and trips where you can't wash. Synthetic for hard, sweaty efforts, hot days and anything that gets soaked. A blend gives you some of each.
In this guide
It's the first layer in your layering system, under a fleece or insulated jacket and a waterproof. Most of the time it's a long or short sleeved top, sometimes with leggings or long johns under your trousers.
The reason it matters is sweat. Even on a cold day you sweat while you walk uphill. If that sweat sits against your skin, it chills you the moment you stop. A good base layer keeps it off your skin in one of two ways. Merino takes it up as vapour into the fibre. Synthetic draws it through the fabric so it evaporates from the outside.
That's also why cotton is a poor choice. It holds sweat against your skin, gets heavy and stays cold for hours. See how the layering system works for what goes over the top.
| Merino | Synthetic | |
|---|---|---|
| Warm when damp | Yes, stays warm | Less so, but dries quickly |
| Drying time | Slower | Fast |
| Smell after a few days | Very little | Polyester holds on to body odour; an anti-odour treatment helps |
| Toughness | Can wear through under pack straps | Generally stands up better to straps, rock and washing |
| Feel | Soft, rarely clammy | Smooth, can feel clammy when soaked |
| Cost | Costs more | Costs less |
Neither is better across the board. The rest of this guide is about which suits the way you get out.
Merino doesn't heat you up or cool you down on its own. What it does is smooth out the swings between too hot and too cold, which is what you want on a day of climbs and stops.
Is merino wool warm? It's warm for its weight, and it stays warm when damp. Each merino fibre has a natural wave, called crimp, which traps small pockets of air when the fibres sit together. The fibres are springy, so they keep that air even when damp. How warm a particular top feels still depends on its weight and knit, not only the fibre.
Does merino keep you cool? It helps. Wool takes up sweat as vapour into the fibre, commonly quoted as up to a third of its own weight, before it feels damp. Then it releases that moisture to the air. When you're hot and sweating, the evaporation helps you cool. When you stop and cool down, it slows. That's why merino suits days with lots of stops.
There's a small bonus when you stop after a hard climb. Wool gives off a little heat as it takes up moisture. It isn't much, but it takes the edge off that first chill.
Does merino dry quickly? Not as quickly as synthetic. If you soak it, in a downpour, a river crossing or a heavy sweat, it takes longer to dry. It stays warmer while it's damp, which is the trade-off.
Polyester tends to hold on to body odour, which is why a synthetic top can smell after one hard day. Merino handles odour much better. It keeps your skin drier, and the fibre holds on to smells until it's washed rather than giving them off. In practice you can wear a Kepler top for several days on a trek and still sit next to people at the end of it. That's the main reason people who try merino on a multi-day trip keep wearing it.
It needs a gentler wash than synthetic: cool water, wool detergent, no fabric conditioner and line dry. See how to wash merino wool clothing.
Synthetic fibres, mostly polyester, barely absorb water at all. Instead, the gaps in the fabric draw liquid sweat away from your skin and spread it across the outside, where it evaporates. This is wicking. How well it works depends on the fabric's construction (the yarn, the knit and how open it is), which is why two polyester tops can feel very different on a hard climb. Wicking is the fastest way to get rid of sweat, which is why synthetics suit running and cycling, where you're sweating for hours at a time.
Synthetic fabrics generally stand up to abrasion, rough use and repeated washing better than pure merino, and they cost less. The catch is smell, because polyester holds on to body odour. We treat our Koulin tops with Polygiene, an anti-odour treatment, so you can wear them more between washes.
A rule of thumb for breathability: hold the fabric up to the light. The more light that comes through, the more air and heat it lets out. Koulin has mesh panels under the arms and across the back for that reason.
A blend mixes merino with synthetic to get some of both. Aztec is half merino and half recycled polyester, knitted so the merino sits against your skin. It's lighter and tougher than pure merino, dries faster and still resists smell.
Our Kepler boxers, long johns and leggings use corespun merino: a stretchy nylon core wrapped in merino wool. It's still mostly merino, but it keeps its shape and lasts longer in places that take a lot of stretch and rubbing.
Hillwalking. Steady effort with stops for views, food and navigation. Merino suits this best because it evens out the hot climbs and cold summits, so Kepler is the one to start with. If you sweat heavily or walk fast, Koulin or the Aztec blend copes better. Our hillwalking base layer guide goes into more detail.
Running and cycling. High output, lots of sweat, few stops. Synthetic, close fitting and light, like Koulin. Merino works for long, steady rides in cold weather, when you want warmth more than drying speed.
Winter and cold weather. Merino, and think about Kepler long johns or leggings under your trousers too. Choose a warmer weight for low-output days like winter walking with long stops, or for sleeping in at camp.
Multi-day trips and travel. Merino, because you can wear the same top for days. A blend is a good choice if you're also carrying a heavy pack.
On the water: paddling and sailing. You'll get wet from spray and wind, then sit still. Merino stays warmer when damp, so it's the better choice for cold days with a lot of sitting. Synthetic dries fastest, so it suits warm days and anything where you expect to be in and out of the water.
Base layer fabric weight is measured in grams per square metre (gsm). As a rough guide:
Fabric weight tells you how warm a top is. Fibre fineness tells you how it feels. Merino fibres are much finer than ordinary wool, and finer fibres bend against your skin instead of prickling. That's what "ultrafine" means on a merino label, and why most people find ultrafine merino doesn't itch.
A base layer should fit close to your skin. If it hangs loose, sweat has nowhere to go and cold air gets in. Flat seams stop rubbing under pack straps, and a longer back stays tucked in when you reach up. Thumb loops keep sleeves in place under a fleece.
Kepler: when comfort on long, stop-start days matters most. 100% ultrafine merino at 17.2 micron. It evens out your temperature between climbs and stops and goes days without smelling, so it's the one for hillwalking, winter and trips where you won't be washing. Choose the Kepler Long Sleeve (women's) as your all-rounder, the Short Sleeve (women's) for warmer days, or the Zip Top when you want to vent on the climbs. Add the Kepler Long John or women's Leggings for cold days.
Aztec: when pure merino wears out or dries too slowly for you. Half merino and half recycled polyester, so it keeps most of merino's comfort and odour resistance but is tougher under pack straps and dries faster. Aztec Long Sleeve (women's).
Koulin: when you're working hard and sweating a lot. Recycled polyester with mesh panels under the arms and across the back, and Polygiene against odour. It gets rid of sweat fastest, for running, cycling and fast hillwalking. Koulin Trail Tee (women's) or Koulin Trail Long Sleeve (women's).
Not after a technical base layer? Picu is a different kind of top: a recycled polyester and organic cotton blend that looks and feels like a cotton tee but dries much faster. It suits travel, warm treks and relaxed days more than hard efforts on the hill. Picu Long Sleeve (women's).
See all merino base layers, or the full men's and women's ranges.
Next up in our series The Complete Guide to Outdoor Clothing: Continue building your layering system by moving up into the fleecy world of the midlayer.