When George Finch designed an insulated suit jacket and trousers for the 1922 Everest Expedition, mountaineers openly laughed at his balloon fabric and eiderdown contraption. Well, they did at first. They weren’t laughing when they realised how much warmer he was!
Now, insulated jackets are an essential part of our outdoor wardrobe – lightweight and packable bundles of warmth that allow us to stay out for longer and explore incredible landscapes in extreme cold. But choosing one isn’t just as simple as deciding whether you want down or synthetic insulation. Here’s everything you need to know to choose an insulated jacket.
- What are insulated jackets?
- Down jackets guide
- Synthetic jackets guide
- Which is better, down or synthetic?
- How warm should my insulated jacket be?
- What features do I need?
Insulated jackets are jackets filled with either down or man-made synthetic insulation to trap the heat generated by your body. The insulation works by creating ‘loft’, a deep fluffy structure that creates lots of tiny pockets of air between the feathers or fibres. Still air is a fantastic insulator which is why insulated jackets are so much warmer than other outdoor layers.
The main purpose of insulated jackets is to keep you warm when you’re stationary for long periods or when your standard layering system isn’t quite warm enough for the conditions. Insulated jackets vary dramatically, from jackets that are low profile enough to be used as a midlayer to oversized belay jackets designed to be worn over everything, including your waterproof jacket.
Down jackets are filled with the light fluffy feathers found under the breast and underbelly of ducks and geese. Because they’re so fluffy, these down ‘filaments’ create loads of insulating loft for very little weight. Despite innovations in synthetic insulation, down is still the best insulator we have with an incredible warmth for its weight. Down is also highly compressible, squashing down small and rebounding back into shape again without getting damaged. These properties are really useful when you’re trying to pack light or you’re short of pack space.
What do fill power and fill weight mean?
Fill power (FP) tells you about the down quality and is a measurement of how much loft the down creates (how fluffy it is). Fill power measures the volume of air that 20g of down occupies under strict scientific conditions. (In case you were wondering, the number represents how many cubic centimetres a gram of down lofts to. So, 750FP means that 1g of down lofts to 750cm³). Higher fill power down has a better warmth to weight ratio so 100g of 800FP down will be warmer than 100g of 650FP down.
Fill weight is a measure of how many grams of down is inside your jacket. This is where it gets a bit complicated. Jacket warmth depends on both the fill power and the fill weight. This can make it quite hard to compare the warmth of down jackets with different fill powers. That said, when you’re comparing between high quality down (e.g. between 650FP and 750FP), fill weight will give you the best indication of how warm each jacket will be.
Which is warmer, duck or goose down?
It very much depends on the fill power of the down. As geese have larger feathers, they generally produce higher fill power down which is more expensive. The best quality duck down is around 650FP whereas the highest quality goose down can sometimes reach 900FP (but only in very rare circumstances). All the down we use is ethically sourced and certified by the Responsible Down Standard as meeting the highest standards of animal welfare.
What do box wall and stitch-through construction mean?
Box wall and stitch-through are different types of baffle construction. Down jackets are made with lots of baffles, separate compartments that hold the down in place and stop it migrating (sinking to the bottom).
Stitch-through means exactly what it sounds like: each baffle has been stitched all the way through the jacket fabric (like in the picture above). Stitch-through construction is the lightest and the most compressible, but it can create cold spots along the lines of the stitching.
Box wall construction uses a divider of fabric between each baffle which means each baffle is shaped like a… well, box. Box wall construction allows the down to loft better, but the extra fabric does add weight and makes your jacket slightly less compressible.
What is hydrophobic down?
Hydrophobic down is down that has been treated with a durable water repellent (DWR). The big… downside of down is what happens to it when it gets damp. When down gets wet, the filaments absorb water, collapse and clump together, completely losing their warmth-trapping structure. Down also takes a long time to dry out and usually needs to be tumble dried to effectively de-clump it. Hydrophobic down repels water and body moisture for longer and dries quicker. The DownTek™ PFC-Free Water Repellent Down we use stays dry 13.5x longer than untreated down.
Synthetic jackets are filled with man-made polyester fibres that are designed to replicate the properties of down. Like down, synthetic insulation is warm, lightweight and compressible. Unlike down, the polyester fibres don’t absorb water so synthetic insulation keeps its warmth-trapping properties even when wet. This makes synthetic jackets ideal for wet climates (like our infamously rainy British Isles), or for active use when you’re likely to get extremely sweaty! There are lots of different types of synthetic insulation – from carpets of fibres to individual ‘filaments’ designed to mimic down – each with their own advantages.
How is synthetic insulation measured?
Most brands measure synthetic insulation by grams per square metre – you might see this listed as either gsm or g/m². However, because there are so many different types of synthetic insulation, each with a different warmth-to-weight ratio, gsm only really helps you to compare between jackets using the exact same insulation.
What is PrimaLoft®?
PrimaLoft® is a brand of synthetic insulation, first developed in the 1980s to provide a water-resistant alternative to down for military jackets and sleeping bags. Their fibres are specially treated to make them water repellent for even better wet weather performance. PrimaLoft® Gold provides the same amount of warmth-to-weight as 550FP down.
PrimaLoft® became the market leader for synthetic insulation in the 1990s – to such an extent that people often refer to all synthetic insulation as ‘primaloft’ (in much the same way we call vacuum cleaners 'hoovers'). We exclusively use PrimaLoft® fill for our jackets as they provide the highest quality of synthetic insulation available.
What is ‘active insulation’?
Active insulation is a special type of synthetic insulation that can be combined with more breathable or stretchy fabrics for high intensity activities. Most forms of insulation (including down) need to be combined with dense-weave fabrics to stop the insulation from escaping. These fabrics tend to be windproof but not very breathable. Active insulation stays together in one sheet which means we can make more breathable insulated jackets like the Katabatic that allow sweat and excess heat to escape.
Generally speaking, down jackets are better for dry, cold environments and synthetic jackets are better for damp, cold environments. But with synthetic insulation technology closing the gap on down’s warmth, weight and compressibility, and hydrophobic down improving down’s wet performance, it’s not quite as simple as it used to be.
|The best warmth-to-weight ratio||Loses all its warmth when wet|
|More compressible than synthetics||Harder to look after in the damp|
|Lasts for years with good care||Takes a long time to dry out|
|Natural, renewable and biodegradable||More expensive|
|Keeps its insulation when wet||Not as warm as down at the top end|
|Water repellent and fast-drying||Heavier for the same warmth as down|
|Very easy to wash and care for||Less compressible than down|
|Cheaper than down||Can lose loft after repeated heavy use|
Insulated jackets work by retaining the heat your body generates, so how warm your jacket needs to be depends largely on how active you are when you’re wearing it. If you’re buying a jacket for long, stationary belays in high mountain environments, you’ll need a very warm jacket indeed – something like the Fantom or 0Hiro. But jackets like these would be far too hot for hiking in and overkill for lunch stops, where a lighter jacket like the Katabatic, Talini or Heiko would be more suitable.
You might also want to think about what kind of temperatures you intend to use your jacket in. Do you need an insulated jacket for winter walking in Scotland and alpine conditions, or just a bit of back-up warmth for spring and autumn?
Once you’ve decided what type of insulation you need and how warm you need it to be, you might want to think about what kind of features you’ll find useful. Insulated jackets vary quite a lot depending on the intended end use.
Ask yourself what your priority is: weight or durability? Hardwearing fabrics like the 0Hiro’s nylon 6,6 are useful if your jacket is going to take a beating. Otherwise, you can probably get away with a lightweight nylon ripstop. Water resistance is always useful which is why all our insulated jackets are treated with a PFC-free durable water repellent.
Are you going to wear your insulated jacket over other layers, or do you need it to fit under your shell as a midlayer? Jackets designed for moving in tend to have zoned insulation (more insulation in the body and less in the arms) and narrower baffles.
Narrower, smaller baffles like those on the Filoment and Talini are easier to move in but they don’t provide as much loft and warmth as larger baffles (like those found on the Fantom). Micro baffles usually use a stitch-through construction which creates more cold spots.
An insulated hood provides vital extra warmth in the very coldest conditions. However, they do add extra weight and faff to your jacket which may be unnecessary if you’re intending to use it as a midlayer under your shell. Helmet-compatible hoods are useful if you’re going to be using your insulated jacket for climbing or mountaineering.
Two-way zips are useful for climbing and mountaineering as they make it easier to get to your belay device without your jacket getting in the way.
A Warm, Fuzzy Feeling On Top Of That Warm, Fuzzy Feeling
It’s harder than ever to choose an insulated jacket now that the performance differences are so narrow. The good news is it’s possible to make a sustainable choice, whichever type of fill you opt for. We’ve been using Responsible Down Standard approved down for years to ensure our down meets the highest standards of animal welfare. And we’re also now using recycled down in our Filoment Jacket and Filoment Vest to keep perfectly useable down out of landfill. On top of that, we’ve specifically chosen types of Primaloft® insulation with extremely high levels of recycled content – 100% recycled for the Heiko and Sierra Vest. That'll definitely give you a warm, fuzzy feeling!